Connect with us

Opinion

Facebook vs ARCON: Presidential Aide O’tega Ogra Got It Wrong And Should Not Drag Presidency Into Murky Waters

Published

on

Facebook

By Ewa Izuchukwu

adron lemon friday

 

It was barely weeks after my honest review that raised questions about Justice Bogoro’s judgment setting aside ARCON’s ₦60 billion notice against Facebook Nigeria, when I got a rejoinder from a surprising and an unexpected source.

Also read: Facebook Nigeria vs ARCON’s judgment: Not about fine but consumer protection at risk of vulnerability

It’s not from Facebook Nigeria, not from Meta’s regional or global policy office, but from our own O’tega Ogra, the Senior Special Assistant to the President on Digital Communications, Engagement and New Media Strategy. His piece, “The Facebook Nigeria Judgment Is Not a Defeat for Consumers. It Is a Victory for the Rule of Law,” summarily argues that the ruling strengthens institutional discipline rather than weaken consumer protection.

Ordinarily, public debate is healthy. Counter-arguments strengthen democratic discourse. But before engaging the substance of Ogra’s arguments, there is an important question that deserve serious considerations, answers: why has a presidential aide become the most visible public defender of a judgment obtained by Meta when the company itself has chosen silence?

Ogra’s writer profile at the end of the rejoinder discloses that he is also Vice President of the Association of Advertisers in Nigeria (ADVAN) and a member of the governing council of the World Federation of Advertisers.

Those are legitimate affiliations. But again, is he speaking as the President’s communications adviser? As an ADVAN executive? Or simply as a private citizen exercising his right to free expression?

The distinction matters because each role carries different responsibilities. When a senior presidential spokesman publicly champions a position that substantially aligns with the interests of a multinational technology company in litigation against a regulatory agency, perceptions matter as much as intentions.

Whatever he intended, the impression created is that the Presidency through its Ogra its spokesman has entered a dispute against a federal government agency. That is an impression no presidential aide should willingly create.

Interestingly, while ADVAN has maintained its longstanding disagreements with ARCON over ongoing advertising industry reforms, its President, Osamede Uwubanmwen, and its Board of Trustees Chairman, Aare Fatai Odeshile have appeared to be relatively restrained in publicly prosecuting this latest chapter of that disagreement. Instead, Ogra has emerged as the new ADVAN spokesman on industry matters.

Whether by design or circumstance, he now appears to be carrying the public argument that others within the association have largely avoided. That should concern him.

A presidential spokesman should be careful not to blur the distinction between public office and negative industry issues, particularly on matters where government itself has a direct stake through one of its regulatory agency.

The Office of the President should not be perceived as attacking a regulatory agency in the media or championing foreign interests ahead of national and consumer interests.

Is this really something to celebrate?

Setting personalities and motives aside and examining Ogra’s main claim, the court did not shield Meta from the law, only that ARCON failed to prove Facebook Nigeria’s relationship to Meta with admissible evidence rather than commercial assumption. But look at what proving that relationship “properly” actually requires in practice.

In the earlier related Abuja suit FHC/ABJ/CS/1701/2022, filed in September 2022, ARCON had gone the route Ogra says the law demands. It sued Meta Platforms Incorporated directly, and on 30 March 2023 the court granted leave to issue and serve the originating summons on Meta in the United States!

If that is what “doing it properly” looks like, then the rule of law Ogra is celebrating is one that only a well-resourced regulator, or a well-resourced litigant, can actually afford to invoke.

An ordinary Nigerian consumer deceived through advertising on Facebook cannot realistically litigate against Meta in California or Delaware. So while lawyers may applaud procedural purity, consumers are left asking a simpler question: who protects us?

Consumer protection is not exclusive to one regulator

It is disappointing that as a senior presidential aide, Ogra does not know that all government agencies have overlapping functions and all government regulatory agencies have consumer protection as their primary mandate, and that is why he would argue that ARCON is not Nigeria’s consumer protection regulator and that this responsibility belongs to the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC).

Government agencies routinely enforce laws within their respective sectors where consumer welfare is implicated. NAFDAC prosecutes misleading advertisements relating to regulated products.

The Central Bank intervenes where financial promotions breach banking regulations. The Securities and Exchange Commission acts against unlawful investment promotions.

The Nigerian Communications Commission protects telecommunications subscribers. None of these agencies declines responsibility simply because the FCCPC also has consumer protection powers.

In fact, quite recently, the National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) recently secured the conviction of a social media content creator for promoting cannabis online.

The court sentenced him to seven years’ imprisonment after finding him guilty under the NDLEA Act for using social media to advertise cannabis products.

The NDLEA did not conclude that because the offending conduct involved advertising, it should wait for ARCON to act. Nor did it argue that advertising regulation fell exclusively within another regulator’s jurisdiction.

It acted because the offence touched directly on its statutory mandate. That is how sectoral regulation works. Government agencies exercise powers within their enabling laws, even where those powers intersect with advertising, consumer welfare or public safety.

The evidentiary bar Ogra defends is not the one Nigerian courts actually apply

Ogra insists that “commercial reality and legal proof are not always the same thing,” and that courts cannot repair a regulator’s evidentiary gaps. That would be a stronger argument if our courts had, in fact, been applying that standard consistently. They have not.

In January, a Lagos High Court in Femi Falana, SAN v. Meta Platforms Inc. held Meta liable as a joint data controller for content on Facebook without requiring Falana to first construct an elaborate paper trail proving Meta’s ownership and control of the platform; the relationship was treated as established fact, because it plainly is.

The Competition and Consumer Protection Tribunal reached a $220 million judgment against “Meta Platforms Incorporated (Facebook) and WhatsApp LLC” jointly on the same basis.

Our law also already possesses a doctrine built for exactly this situation, which is piercing the corporate veil, applied by the Supreme Court in Marina Nominees Ltd v. Federal Board of Inland Revenue to look behind a company shown to be acting as another’s agent, and invoked whenever, per Oyebanji v. State, a corporate form is used to dupe or evade.

None of these courts demanded that a claimant first litigate Meta’s corporate structure from scratch. Only Justice Bogoro’s court did. If Otegra’s “rule of law” means anything, it should mean consistency… the same platform, the same country, should not be a proven data controller in one courtroom and a legal stranger to its own product in another.

As referenced in my earlier piece, Nigeria is not the first place Meta has reached for corporate separateness as a shield, and Ogra’s “burden of proof” framing collapses when set against how other courts have treated the identical argument.

In Kenya, Meta spent years insisting it could not be held responsible for Facebook content moderators because they were technically employed by an outsourcing contractor, Sama; Kenya’s employment court rejected that, and the Court of Appeal upheld the rejection, holding that Meta was the real employer because the moderators did Meta’s work under Meta’s control.

In Australia, Facebook Inc argued in litigation brought by the country’s privacy regulator that only its Irish affiliate, not Facebook Inc itself, conducted business in Australia; the Full Federal Court rejected that, and separately refused Facebook Inc’s own attempt to escape service of the very kind of cross-border process Ogra treats as an unavoidable technicality here.

Ireland’s Data Protection Commission, dealing with the very corporate architecture Meta uses to route around accountability, fined the Irish subsidiary itself €1.2 billion rather than accepting that the structure shielded anyone.

In each of these markets, courts and regulators found a way to hold the platform to account without first demanding a documentary trail that, in practice, only Meta’s own internal filings could ever fully. Indeed, Nigeria’s outcome is the outlier, not the norm.

Mr. Ogra ends his article by urging ADVAN to help foster reconciliation between advertisers and regulators.

That would have been commendable had ADVAN not spent years engaged in legal confrontation with ARCON over issues bordering on regulatory authority.

Let me stop here by emphasizing that the larger issue is no longer whether the presidential aide is entitled to his opinion. Every Nigerian enjoys that right.

The real issue is whether he should be the one leading what increasingly appears to be an industry campaign against a statutory agency of the same Federal Government he has been appointed to serve.

If Mr. Ogra wishes to be the public face of ADVAN’s long-running disagreements with ARCON, that is entirely his prerogative. But public office comes with obligations that demand restraint, neutrality and an acute awareness of perception.

The Office of the President should never be seen, rightly or wrongly, as taking sides in a dispute involving one of its own regulatory agencies and a multinational corporation.

That is why Mr. Ogra should reflect carefully on the implications of his intervention. If he believes so strongly in ADVAN’s cause that he intends to become one of its principal public advocates in its continuing contest with ARCON, then the honourable course would be to first relinquish his role as Senior Special Assistant to the President.

He cannot effectively wear the hat of a presidential spokesman while simultaneously projecting himself as a leading voice in a battle that pits an industry association against an agency of the Federal Government.

This is more so as every response directed at him in this matter inevitably risks being interpreted as a response to the Presidency itself.

That serves neither President Bola Tinubu, whose office ought to remain above such industry disputes, nor the integrity of government institutions.

Also read: Facebook Nigeria vs ARCON’s judgment: Not about fine but consumer protection at risk of vulnerability

Public confidence is not strengthened when a presidential aide appears to be publicly undermining one regulator while defending the legal victory of a private multinational company.

75 / 100 SEO Score
Continue Reading

Opinion

Our Great Tree of Peace: Keynote Address at All Nigeria Rotary Peace Summit

Published

on

Distinguished leaders of government, members of the diplomatic community, representatives of security and law-enforcement agencies, traditional and religious leaders, distinguished guests, fellow Rotary members, ladies and gentlemen:

adron lemon friday

It is an honour to welcome you to the “All Nigeria Rotary Peace Summit.”

The question before us is how to come together, work toward a shared national future, and achieve true and lasting peace.

Nigeria has enormous potential. We have contributed to peace and stability across Africa, including through our work with the Economic Community of West African States and United Nations peacekeeping and Peace Support operations.

Our work in Liberia and other parts of Africa shows that we have the experience and ability to help prevent and manage conflict beyond our borders.

Now it is time to turn those energies inward — to bring our commitment to building peace among our neighbors and the world back home.

But we cannot impose peace. We must nurture it from the very roots of our society so it may grow into a great tree that will feed and shelter all of us under its protective embrace.

As a member of Rotary, when I consider this idea, I look to the philosophy of Positive Peace.

Peace, through this lens, is so much more than the absence of violence. To achieve true and lasting peace, we must consider the attitudes, institutions, and structures that create and sustain peaceful societies.

Here in Nigeria, meaningful peace cannot rely on our security forces and government institutions alone. It requires every level of society to come together for the betterment of all.

To grow Positive Peace from the ground up, Rotary starts from the very foundation of life, as we have done here.
In 2022, Rotary began a program called, “Together for Healthy Families in Nigeria.”

Members of Rotary here in Nigeria and as far away as Germany partnered with federal and state health ministries to make giving birth safer for both mother and child.

The program has helped expectant mothers across three states and the capital receive better and more frequent prenatal care.

Community health workers made nearly 60,000 visits to homes of expectant mothers and spoke with them and their families. We supplied 158 health facilities with contraceptives, medicine, and equipment.

We have already seen positive outcomes. Maternal deaths were reduced by 77%, and newborn deaths were reduced by 45% at supported facilities.

There is more work to do, but we are making progress. This is one way we plant the seeds of peace in Nigeria and around the world — we listen to the community, work with people so they can make their own lives better, and we stay committed to our goals.

With each child born safely to a healthy mother, we ease the burden carried by the Federal Ministry of Health and Social Welfare. We give families a greater sense of safety and security.

This is the beginning of Positive Peace. But members of Rotary do not stop once the seeds of peace are planted.

Since 2020, Nigeria has been free of the deadly grip of the wild poliovirus, which paralyzed and sometimes killed children when their lives had barely begun. And we continue to work with our friends at the World Health Organization and others to keep it that way and address the more recent outbreaks of variant poliovirus.

Rotary also builds peace directly. Members of Rotary clubs across Nigeria devote themselves to building peace every day.

And the year after Nigeria was declared wild polio-free, Rotary worked with Makerere University in Uganda to open a Peace Center, where students — called Peace Fellows — can learn how to build lasting peace both here in Nigeria and across Africa.

Over the years, more than 75 Rotary Peace Fellows have come from Nigeria. Some of our Peace Fellows are even here with us today.

I tell you this not to advertise Rotary (although we can always use new members). I tell you this because I want you to know that Rotary is already a quiet partner in peacebuilding — not only around the world — but here in our shared home.

As members of Rotary, we are not soldiers, ambassadors, or diplomats. We bring people together to find common purpose through service to others. We are here for Nigeria, and we are here to stay.

This year, I have called on every member of Rotary to Create Lasting Impact, and today, my brothers and sisters of Nigeria, I ask the same of every one of us.

I ask us to look at every level of society in Nigeria and consider how we can make all our lives better — not only today, but far into the future of this great nation. We may not speak the same language, worship the same way, or live the same way, but our nation’s future depends on all of us working together.

This summit is an opportunity to turn our shared commitment to peace into practical action — to take mere words and transform them into a bright future for us and all our children.

To my dear friends and family of Rotary here today, I challenge you to make peacebuilding in Nigeria our legacy of lasting impact.

As I have said to the Rotary world time and time again, we must consider how everything we do contributes to peace and pursue that peace purposefully and deliberately.

Rotary can help build confidence between institutions and communities, strengthen public trust, and ease the burden of everyday life that makes peacebuilding that much harder … but we must do so with purpose.

And before we can Create Lasting Impact in Nigeria, we must first have the courage to change ourselves, whether we are members of Rotary or not.

We cannot continue to do what we have always done and expect our great tree of peace to magically sprout from the ground. We must nurture our country and ourselves with all our being.

Give yourselves permission to be changed by what you see and hear at this summit.

That is how lasting impact is achieved — through people who are willing to change, institutions that are prepared to work for everyone, and communities that have the capacity to sustain progress.

And once we allow ourselves to change, we open ourselves to a new future — a future where the circumstances of someone’s birth do not determine their access to justice, opportunity, or dignity.

A future where differences are respected, where violence is rejected, and where we all come together, not as different groups in competition, but as Nigerians in harmony.

As we begin this summit, let us commit to more than resolutions and declarations. Let us commit to stability through change.

Remember that our true measure of success is not the words we share among ourselves today, but the impact of our actions that lasts generation after generation.

And if our commitment to peace is true — if our capacity for change is enough — our children, and their children after them, will enjoy the fruits of our labor under our great tree of peace — protected, safe, and free.

Thank you.

62 / 100 SEO Score
Continue Reading

Opinion

Media Must Distinguish Electoral Reality from Political Wishful Thinking Ahead of 2027

Published

on

Nigeria’s democratic development depends not only on credible elections but also on responsible journalism and an informed electorate. In the view of Nosa Osaikhuiwu, sections of the Nigerian media and political commentary class have fallen short of this responsibility, particularly in their coverage and interpretation of the 2023 presidential election.

adron lemon friday

Writing from Houston, Texas, Osaikhuiwu argues that rather than critically examining the political realities behind the outcome, some media platforms amplified unsubstantiated allegations of electoral fraud by defeated candidates without sufficiently interrogating the evidence. This, he says, has contributed to public distrust and weakened confidence in critical democratic institutions, particularly the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) and the judiciary.

He highlights a key principle of electoral politics that he believes has been largely overlooked: when opposition forces divide their strength among competing candidates, they can strengthen the position of an incumbent under a winner-takes-all system. He cites examples from the United States, including Ross Perot’s impact in 1992 and Ralph Nader’s role in 2000.

Applying the same principle to Nigeria in 2023, Osaikhuiwu notes that Peter Obi and Atiku Abubakar contested separately against President Bola Tinubu. Although their combined votes exceeded Tinubu’s total, elections are decided by the votes secured by individual candidates under established rules, not by post-election addition of rivals’ tallies.

Looking ahead to 2027, he observes a similar opposition configuration emerging, with Atiku and Obi again pursuing separate ambitions. While acknowledging the economic hardships associated with Tinubu’s reforms and the administration’s political vulnerability, Osaikhuiwu stresses that public dissatisfaction does not automatically translate into an organised electoral movement capable of defeating an incumbent.

He criticises suggestions by some media personalities that the 2027 elections will be rigged even before they take place, describing such pronouncements as irresponsible. Journalists, he argues, must interrogate claims, examine evidence and educate the public rather than merely amplify the statements of political actors.

Osaikhuiwu maintains that while there may have been logistical shortcomings in 2023, these did not materially alter the final outcome, which was declared by INEC and upheld through the judicial process. Disagreement with a result, he says, is not in itself evidence of fraud.

He concludes that if the opposition genuinely seeks to defeat Tinubu in 2027, it must address its divisions and build a viable electoral coalition. Individual popularity, social media enthusiasm and public dissatisfaction cannot substitute for organisation, coalition-building and grassroots mobilisation.

“Journalism must educate, not mislead. Political commentary must analyze, not merely amplify. And democracy must be grounded in electoral reality, not political wishful thinking,” he writes.

53 / 100 SEO Score
Continue Reading

Opinion

Nigeria Must Sustain Power Rotation Arrangement, Says Babarinsa

Published

on

Veteran journalist and Chairman of Gaskia Media Limited, Dare Babarinsa, has called on Nigeria to sustain its informal power-rotation arrangement between the North and South, arguing that the system remains important for political stability and national unity.

adron lemon friday

Babarinsa said the presidency should return to the North in 2031 and move back to the South in 2039, maintaining that the arrangement should remain in place until Nigerians develop a more suitable alternative.

He made the position known on Monday, November 2, while delivering a public lecture at the Press Centre, Iyaganku, Ibadan, as part of activities marking the 60th anniversary of the Oyo State Council of the Nigerian Union of Journalists (NUJ).

Speaking on the theme of Nigeria’s political arrangement and the future of the media, Babarinsa acknowledged criticisms of the rotational presidency, particularly from those who believe that every qualified Nigerian should be allowed to contest for the highest political office regardless of region.

However, he argued that Nigeria’s political circumstances make power rotation a practical arrangement for maintaining stability, even if it may not always produce the most suitable candidate.

According to him, the arrangement emerged from political negotiations ahead of the return to civilian rule in 1999, following the deaths of former military Head of State, General Sani Abacha, and the presumed winner of the June 12, 1993 presidential election, Chief Moshood Abiola.

Babarinsa recalled that after Abacha’s death in 1998, General Abdulsalami Abubakar assumed leadership and introduced a transition programme aimed at ending military rule by May 29, 1999.

He said the death of Abiola, who was detained by the military government, created concerns about the political future of the Yoruba people and influenced discussions over the region that should produce Nigeria’s first civilian president after military rule.

The journalist disclosed that he was among members of the Idile Oodua resistance movement who supported the position that the South-West should produce the first president under the new democratic arrangement.

He said he was subsequently mandated by members of the group to consult the late Ooni of Ife, Oba Okunade Sijuwade, who told him that traditional rulers across the country were also holding consultations on the matter.

According to Babarinsa, the discussions contributed to the emergence of two Yoruba presidential candidates in the 1999 election: former President Olusegun Obasanjo of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and Chief Olu Falae, who contested under the Alliance for Democracy and All Peoples Party coalition.

He also recalled that former Vice-President Alex Ekwueme disagreed with the arrangement, arguing that the South-East could not be bound by an agreement reached principally between political interests in the North and South-West.

Babarinsa said he agreed with Ekwueme’s interpretation that power should rotate between the North and South rather than among the six geopolitical zones.

He explained that the arrangement had continued through successive administrations, including the emergence of former President Goodluck Jonathan following the death of President Umaru Yar’Adua and the subsequent election of former President Muhammadu Buhari.

With President Bola Tinubu currently in office, Babarinsa argued that the existing arrangement should be sustained, with power returning to the North after the current administration and subsequently moving back to the South.

To support his argument, he compared Nigeria’s power-sharing arrangement with the confessional system adopted in Lebanon in 1943, under which key political offices were allocated to different religious communities to promote political balance.

He said Nigeria could learn from such arrangements, insisting that political compromises sometimes become necessary in countries with diverse ethnic, religious and regional interests.

“If we intend to keep Nigeria, then we need to make this special arrangement work until future generations are able to make a better arrangement,” he said.

Babarinsa reflects on Ibadan’s journalism legacy

Beyond the political question, Babarinsa used the lecture to examine the history of journalism in Ibadan and the contribution of the city to the development of Nigeria’s media industry.

He described Ibadan as a major centre of political and media influence, noting that its newspapers had produced some of the country’s most prominent journalists, editors and public commentators.

He recalled the establishment of the Nigerian Tribune in 1949 by Chief Obafemi Awolowo and the creation of the Sketch newspaper group in 1964 by the then Premier of the Western Region, Chief Ladoke Akintola.

He also highlighted the contributions of prominent journalists, including Felix Adenaike, Segun Osoba and Peter Ajayi, whom he described as the Three Musketeers of the Nigerian media during the Second Republic.

According to him, the trio wielded considerable influence in the industry through their leadership positions at the Tribune and Sketch newspaper groups.

Babarinsa also acknowledged the contributions of former journalists and columnists, including Alhaji Lateef Jakande, Chief Bola Ige, Chief Olabisi Onabanjo, Aare Afe Babalola and Dr Tai Solarin.

He said the history of journalism in Ibadan was closely connected to the political development of the country, recalling the debates on issues such as the International Monetary Fund loan, diarchy and rotational presidency.

The journalist urged members of the profession to preserve that tradition by ensuring that the media remained a platform for informed public debate and the promotion of ideas capable of strengthening Nigeria.

Media organisations urged to embrace digital transformation

Addressing the challenges facing the industry, Babarinsa warned that traditional media organisations must urgently adapt to the changing media environment or risk losing relevance.

He said the internet had disrupted conventional news production and distribution, creating new opportunities while also allowing unregulated online platforms to compete with established media organisations.

According to him, several traditional newspapers have established online platforms, but their digital presence has not translated into the level of revenue needed to sustain their operations.

He cited the decline of once-dominant media organisations such as the Daily Times and Sketch as examples of the changes that have reshaped the industry.

Babarinsa recalled that Sketch newspaper had a daily circulation of about 60,000 copies during the 1970s and 1980s but had since ceased publication, with its former premises converted into a shopping mall.

He also expressed concern over declining newspaper readership among young Nigerians, warning that a society with an increasingly uninformed population could struggle to appreciate and defend democracy.

The Gaskia Media chairman said media organisations must follow their audiences into the digital space and develop business models that can sustain quality journalism.

He disclosed that his organisation had also decided to strengthen its online presence through the publication of a digital magazine, beginning with an online news blog.

Journalists urged to defend democracy and uphold professional standards

Babarinsa further reminded journalists of their role in Nigeria’s democratic development, particularly during the struggle against military rule.

He said members of the Nigerian press had suffered imprisonment, exile and other forms of persecution in the fight for the restoration of democracy, with some journalists paying the ultimate price.

He maintained that journalists therefore had a responsibility to protect the democratic system and ensure that the country’s electoral processes remained credible.

With the 2027 general election approaching, he urged media professionals to play their part by providing accurate information and encouraging informed public participation.

The Independent National Electoral Commission has scheduled the presidential and National Assembly elections for January 16, 2027, while governorship and State Houses of Assembly elections are fixed for February 6, 2027.

Babarinsa said journalists must remain committed to the fundamental principles of the profession, stressing that factual accuracy should remain central to news reporting while allowing room for responsible advocacy.

He urged journalists to advocate for the national interest, rather than restrict their work to positions that may be politically convenient.

Calls for greater inclusion of young journalists and women

Looking towards the future, Babarinsa called for greater opportunities for young journalists and women in the profession, saying the industry must deliberately prepare a new generation of media leaders.

He cited the careers of prominent journalists who assumed major editorial and management positions at relatively young ages, including Peter Enahoro, Olusegun Osoba, Yemi Ogunbiyi, Yakubu Mohammed, Ray Ekpu and Adamu Ciroma.

According to him, the history of Nigerian journalism demonstrates that young professionals have consistently played important roles in driving the industry forward.

He urged established media practitioners to listen to younger colleagues, particularly members of Generation Z, and create opportunities for them to contribute to the future of the profession.

Babarinsa also called for more deliberate efforts to bring women into leadership positions, noting that the industry could no longer remain dominated by men.

He expressed optimism about the future of journalism, despite concerns over poor remuneration, declining newspaper circulation and competition from digital platforms.

The veteran journalist concluded by urging the profession to embrace change, drawing attention to the need for innovation in newspaper production, technology and audience engagement.

Quoting a principle he attributed to Professor Ladipo Adamolekun, Babarinsa said the media industry must adapt to changing realities to remain relevant.

“Adapt or Die!” he declared.

67 / 100 SEO Score
Continue Reading

Trending News